By Rebecca Kelly, lawyer and co-founder of shizl
For freelancers, agreeing to a new project can be exciting. There is a new client, new work and, hopefully, a new source of income. But getting the work is only half the job.
The contract underpinning the relationship can be just as important as the work itself. From advising businesses that engage freelancers and contractors, I regularly see problems arising from the same four areas: scope, payment, intellectual property and employment status.
None of these issues is particularly difficult to address at the outset. The difficulty comes when freelancers assume that everyone has the same understanding of the arrangement.
My advice is simple: never leave the fundamentals to assumption. Put them in writing before you start.
1. What exactly are you being paid to deliver?
Scope creep is one of the most common ways a straightforward freelance project can become a dispute.
A client may genuinely believe that an additional task is included in the agreed fee, while the freelancer believes it falls outside the original brief. Neither party necessarily has acted unreasonably. The problem is that the scope was never clearly defined.
A written statement of work (or similar) should set out exactly what the freelancer is being engaged to deliver.
It should cover the key deliverables, project start date, expected duration, deadlines and, where possible, the expected end date. It should also specify how many revisions are included and, importantly, what happens when the client asks for something outside the original scope.
How will that additional work be priced? Who needs to approve it? Does approval need to be in writing?
These details may seem administrative when a project is getting started, but they can become extremely important if the relationship later becomes strained.
The principle is simple: if you cannot clearly establish what was agreed at the beginning, it becomes much harder to establish when the work is finished.
2. When exactly are you going to be paid?
Payment terms should never be an afterthought.
Many payment disputes arise because the original agreement did not clearly establish when payment was due, what triggered payment or what would happen if the client was unhappy with the work.
Freelancers should agree a clear payment schedule, using specific dates wherever possible rather than vague milestones such as “on completion”.
The contract should also address late payment. Consider including an express right to suspend work if invoices remain unpaid beyond an agreed period, as well as a provision dealing with interest on late payments.
The key is to agree to these terms before the work begins. If a client does not pay, do not allow overdue invoices to accumulate. Chase promptly and, where the contract allows it, remind the client that you have the right to suspend services if payment is not made.
The bigger the unpaid debt becomes, the greater the freelancer’s exposure.
3. Who owns the work you create?
Intellectual property is one of the areas most likely to be misunderstood when a freelancer and client start working together.
There is a common assumption that if a client has paid for a piece of work, it automatically owns the copyright in that work. That is not the case.
Under section 11 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, the author of a copyright work is generally the first owner of copyright, subject to the statutory rules relating to employees. Unlike in an employment relationship, there is no legal principle stating that commissioning a freelancer automatically transfers copyright to the client. In fact the opposite applies – the freelancer will continue to own the copyright UNLESS it is expressly transferred to the client, by a written assignment.
In other words, being paid for work does not, by itself, determine who owns the intellectual property.
The contract needs to address the issue.
This matters particularly for freelancers working in areas such as software development, design, copywriting, photography, marketing and content creation, where the work produced can become a valuable business asset.
Freelancers should pay close attention to the IP provisions in a client’s standard contract. It is easy to sign an agreement transferring ownership of everything created during an engagement without appreciating the implications for future work.
For businesses, the consequences can be even more serious. I have seen situations where a company preparing for a sale or investment discovers that intellectual property it considers fundamental to its business is actually owned by the freelancer who created it. That can create a significant commercial problem at precisely the wrong time.
Never assume that payment determines IP ownership. Check the contract and make sure it reflects the agreement between you and your client.
4. Don’t assume that calling yourself self-employed settles your status
Another common misconception is that employment status is determined simply by what the contract says.
Calling someone a “freelancer”, “contractor” or “self-employed” is not necessarily decisive. Employment status involves looking at the reality of the relationship, including factors such as the degree of control, mutuality of obligation and whether the individual is genuinely operating a business on their own account.
The same applies to IR35. Working through a limited company does not automatically remove IR35 considerations. The actual working relationship remains important.
Hybrid working has also made working arrangements increasingly varied. Contractors may work alongside permanent employees, use company systems and become closely integrated into a business.
For both the business and the contractor, it is therefore important to consider not just what the contract says, but how the relationship operates in practice.
Don’t wait until something goes wrong
The strongest negotiating position a freelancer has is usually before the work starts.
Once the work has been completed, an invoice is overdue and the parties disagree about what was promised, it is much harder to negotiate the fundamentals.
That is why freelancers should have a signed consultancy agreement or terms of engagement in place before starting work, alongside a clear statement of work for each assignment.
Changes to a project can then be recorded as the work progresses. An additional revision round, a new deadline or an extra piece of work can often be agreed by email, provided the original contract allows written confirmation to vary the arrangement.
The important thing is to create a record. A conversation can seem perfectly clear at the time and yet be remembered very differently six months later.
The four questions every freelancer should ask
Before starting a new assignment, make sure you can answer four questions:
- What am I delivering?
- When am I getting paid?
- Who owns what I create?
- What happens if the deal changes?
Get those answers in writing before you start and you will have removed much of the uncertainty that can turn an ordinary freelance assignment into a legal dispute.
Freelancers do have legal protection. The problem is that they often fail to put themselves in the strongest possible position to use it.
Put it in writing. Don’t rely on assumptions, handshakes or conversations that everyone may remember differently.
Protecting your freelance business
For freelancers who want a straightforward way to put the right contractual protections in place, shizl.com can help you create the agreements you need to work with greater confidence and ensure the key terms of your freelance work are properly covered.